Scouting report · QB · NY Giants
J.J. McCarthy
QB33 in Superflex TE-premium dynasty leagues, and still climbing the age curve.
#129 overall · age 23 · 2024 round 1, pick 10 · 3rd season
NYGQuarterback · QB33
Standard points a game
This week · week 8 · Standard
0.0
No game this week
Bye · injury data read Sun, Nov 1, 12:33 p.m. ET
Swindlr's season form: Sleeper has no projection for him this week
Rest of season · redraft standard
#431 · QB42
Value 360 · 12 teams
Dynasty · SF TE+
#129 · QB33
Value 1,966 · 12 teams
Latest15 real trades for him in public Sleeper leagues, the sample's last two weeks
Dynasty value · SF TE+
1,966
▼ 433 · last 3 weeks of games
Rank
#129 · QB33
Overall · position
2026 Standard / game
9.2
3 games
Age
23
3 seasons in
In a year
+5%
2,063 · about #120 next year
Recalculated: today's model on the games through each week, valued at today's point in the season. It shows what each week's games did to his value, not the values Swindlr showed at the time.
Swindlr records its published values weekly from Oct 28, 2026; they'll appear here as a record beside this chart.
Every format
12-team leagues. Tap a format to see him in it.
Where his value comes from · SF TE+
This season 5%Next two seasons 23%Later 71%
His projection (12.1 a game) doesn't clear a replacement-level quarterback yet, so his value is all upside: the model's allowance for him becoming more than that, which it makes wider in a player's first three seasons. It's the least certain part of any value.
Splits
Regular season · week 8 of 2026 (in progress)
| Season | G | Cmp | Att | Pass yds | Pass TD | Int | Rush yds | Rush TD | Standard / G |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 10 | 140 | 243 | 1,632 | 11 | 12 | 181 | 4 | 13.7 |
| 2026 | 3 | 31 | 49 | 495 | 1 | 1 | 29 | 0 | 9.2 |
2026 week by week · Standard points
What he's worth in a trade
SF TE+
Real trades · 85 in the last year · 80 in dynasty Superflex leagues
The last 90 days of the sample, dynasty leagues: 36 trades, 33 Superflex or 2QB and 3 one-QB, 26 with a TE premium. Every trade with him, by format →
Traded 12 times in dynasty leagues the week of Oct 19–25, 2026: what managers gave for him that week.
Managers have been getting him for less than this
In 8 SF TE+ trades since October where he went alone, what came back for him was about 0.53× his value here (the middle half of them 0.34× to 0.79×). The market prices J.J. lower than Swindlr does.
What managers actually gave for J.J. in completed trades in public Sleeper leagues, leagues like SF TE+ first. Each shows the date and the league's settings; the price is what was agreed then, and the line under it is today's value, a different thing. Two-team trades of up to four pieces a side; none is left out for disagreeing with Swindlr. No league or manager names. 10 of them look lopsided at today's values (values move after a trade, with injuries and role changes, so a fair price then can look lopsided now); none is left out.
- Oct 25, 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy + Tyler Warren + 2028 2nd for two 2027 1stsToday on the Dynasty SF board: 6,336 for his side, 4,134 for the otherCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 22, 2026 · 10-team dynasty Superflex, TE +1J.J. McCarthy for 2027 2nd + 2027 3rdToday on the Dynasty SF board: 1,888 for his side, 1,248 for the otherCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 21, 2026 · 12-team dynasty Superflex, TE +0.5J.J. McCarthy for 2028 2ndToday on the Dynasty SF board: 1,888 for his side, 661 for the otherCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 21, 2026 · 10-team dynasty Superflex, TE +0.5J.J. McCarthy + 2027 4th for Emmett JohnsonToday on the Dynasty SF board: 2,181 for his side, 1,595 for the otherCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 21, 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy for 2027 3rdToday on the Dynasty SF board: 1,888 for his side, 377 for the otherCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 21, 2026 · 12-team dynasty Superflex, TE +0.5Brock Purdy + J.J. McCarthy for 2027 1st + 2028 1st + 2029 2ndToday on the Dynasty SF board: 7,489 for his side, 4,177 for the otherCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
Equal value today · Swindlr's estimate
Not real trades: packages that land within a few percent of J.J.'s value in SF TE+ now. A two-for-one shows the pair's total less the roster spot the second player takes, as the calculator counts it. Open one to see who wins it.
In your league
Make the move for J.J..
Values are Swindlr's estimates for 12-team leagues, updated with every week's stats (through week 8 of 2026 (in progress)). "In a year" is the same production a year older, on the age curve the model is tuned with; news, role changes and the next rookie class aren’t in it. Stats: nflverse (CC-BY 4.0).
Stats from Sleeper’s weekly stat lines, regular season, through week 8 of 2026 (in progress) (nflverse’s box scores fill a week Sleeper lacks); teams and injuries from Sleeper, Nov 1. Where the numbers come from.