What managers actually gave.
Real trades: J.J. McCarthy
What the trades show
19 trades match with J.J. McCarthy, Oct 27, 2025 to Oct 26, 2026.
The same search in any QB or TE setting: 80 Superflex or 2QB, 4 one-QB; 65 with a TE premium, 19 without.
When J.J. McCarthy went alone · 7 trades
One piece back: Jalen Milroe, Aaron Jones Sr., Dalton Schultz, Justin Fields, 2027 3rd, 2027 4th.
Swindlr's reading · today's trade values, not the price then
- Superflex: in 7 trades where he went alone, what came back was about 0.36× his trade value (the middle half 0.2× to 0.68×). About 1× agrees with Swindlr; above, managers paid more.
- One-QB: 0 trades where he went alone, too few to read.
Trade value is the calculator's measure in the standard Dynasty Superflex and Dynasty 1QB formats, 12 teams, as of 2026-11-01; it doesn't change with TE premium or league size. A value that moved since a trade is a change of view, not a bad trade.
Rookie pick
League
QB
TE premium
Scoring
Period
The trades
1–19 of 19, newest first
| Date | League | Side with J.J. McCarthy | Got back | Swindlr today | Calculator |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 25, 202610-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 10-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy + Tyler Warren + 2028 2nd | two 2027 1sts | Calculator | |
| Oct 21, 202610-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 10-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy | 2027 3rd | Calculator | |
| Oct 7, 202612-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 12-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy | 2027 3rd + 2028 3rd | Calculator | |
| Sep 30, 202610-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 10-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy | Aaron Jones Sr. | Calculator | |
| Sep 28, 202614-team dynasty 1QB, PPRCalculator | 14-team dynasty 1QB, PPR | Aaron Rodgers + Dontayvion Wicks + J.J. McCarthy | Baker Mayfield + Keon Coleman + 2027 4th | Calculator | |
| Sep 28, 202624-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 24-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy + 2027 3rd | Cade Klubnik + Demond Claiborne | Calculator24 teams → 16 | |
| Sep 24, 202612-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 12-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy | 2027 4th | Calculator | |
| Sep 7, 202610-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 10-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | Jahmyr Gibbs + J.J. McCarthy | Jordan Addison + Ashton Jeanty + 2028 1st + 2028 3rd | Calculator | |
| Aug 17, 202610-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 10-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy | Dalton Schultz | Calculator | |
| Jul 30, 202612-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 12-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | Kyler Murray + J.J. McCarthy + Ladd McConkey | Matthew Stafford + Michael Pittman Jr. + Chig Okonkwo + Bryce Young | Calculator | |
| Jun 23, 202612-team dynasty 1QB, PPRCalculator | 12-team dynasty 1QB, PPR | Sam Darnold + J.J. McCarthy | Jared Goff | Calculator | |
| Jun 16, 202612-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | 12-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy + Keon Coleman | 2026 3rd + 2026 4th | drafted pick | |
| Apr 30, 202612-team dynasty Superflex, half PPRCalculator | 12-team dynasty Superflex, half PPR | J.J. McCarthy | Jalen Milroe | Calculator | |
| Apr 29, 202614-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 14-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | Jakobi Meyers + J.J. McCarthy | Malik Willis | Calculator | |
| Apr 28, 202612-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | 12-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy + 2026 1st | Jaxson Dart + Luther Burden III + 2026 2nd | drafted pick | |
| Mar 16, 202610-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 10-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy | Justin Fields | Calculator | |
| Feb 25, 202610-team dynasty Superflex, PPRCalculator | 10-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | Trey McBride + J.J. McCarthy | Oronde Gadsden + Jaxson Dart + 2027 3rd | Calculator | |
| Feb 21, 202612-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | 12-team dynasty Superflex, PPR | J.J. McCarthy + 2026 3rd | 2026 2nd + 2027 2nd | drafted pick | |
| Jan 20, 202616-team dynasty Superflex, half PPRCalculator | 16-team dynasty Superflex, half PPR | Tee Higgins + J.J. McCarthy | Aaron Rodgers + Garrett Wilson | Calculator |
“Swindlr today” is each side's values added up in the standard format nearest that league, as of 2026-11-01: a reading, not what the trade was worth when it was made. A sum overstates a package of several pieces, and leaves out the roster spot a player takes and a pick doesn't. A dash: a pick from a draft already held.
Sources & methodology
Completed trades in public Sleeper leagues that Swindlr samples (2,256 leagues), read once a week, Dec 31, 2025 to Oct 26, 2026. Private leagues and other platforms aren't in it, so counts describe this sample, not every league.
What's in the sample, and what isn't
Kept: two-team trades of one to four pieces a side, with at least one player, every player one Swindlr values, from the last twelve months. Left out: three-team trades, pick-for-pick swaps, sides of five or more, and trades with kickers, team defenses or players Swindlr doesn't value. Each trade keeps its date (Eastern time) and its league's type, size, QB format, PPR and TE premium; league, team and manager names were never collected.
Superflex counts 2QB leagues (the sample doesn't tell them apart). A pick is its season and round; the sample doesn't record its slot or whose pick it was.
The calculator link carries the league type, team count (8 to 16), Superflex or one QB, PPR and TE premium (0, 0.5 or 1), rounding to the nearest it supports. Roster and bench size, starting lineup, other scoring and a pick's slot aren't carried: picks are valued as mid-round picks of their round, and 2QB leagues count as Superflex.