Two players, one answer.
Carson Benge vs Manny Machado
MLB dynasty, 5x5 categories · 12 teams
| 4,523 | Value | 1,736 |
| 27th | Rank | 123rd |
| 19 HR · 18 SB · .273 | Next season | 25 HR · 9 SB · .251 |
| 24 | Age | 34 |
Straight up · MLB dynasty, 5x5 categories
Benge by 62%
Getting Carson Benge for Manny Machado: highway robbery.
+62%
Every format
Value on the 0–9,999 board
| Format | Carson Benge | Manny Machado | |
|---|---|---|---|
| MLB redraft, 5x5 categories | 3,176 #67 | 3,149 #68 | Even |
| MLB dynasty, 5x5 categories | 4,523 #27 | 1,736 #123 | Benge +62% |
| MLB redraft, points | 1,599 #121 | 2,103 #99 | Machado +24% |
| MLB dynasty, points | 2,170 #99 | 662 #187 | Benge +70% |
| MLB redraft, 5x5 OBP and SV+H | 2,459 #82 | 2,928 #67 | Machado +16% |
| MLB dynasty, 5x5 OBP and SV+H | 3,771 #39 | 1,712 #128 | Benge +55% |
Baseball is a beta: values for 12-team leagues on the boards' 0–9,999 scale; the edge is the straight-up trade check.