Two players, one answer.

Caleb Williams vs Geno Smith

Any format · Week 8 start/sit · PPR

Stats through week 7 of 2026

Week 8 · PPR · 54% held up in 2025

A toss-up

On Sleeper's projections, Geno Smith is projected 0.9 points ahead of Caleb Williams. In the 2025 season, a player projected that far ahead outscored the other 54% of the time. That's close to a coin flip: on these projections neither is the better start, and an injury report or a projection update before kickoff can tip it.

QB · NYJ

Geno Smith

16.6 projected

vs LV · Sun 1:00 PM ET

15.3 a game this season · last 3: 10, 13, 24.5

QB · CHI

Caleb Williams

15.7 projected

@ SEA · Mon 8:15 PM ET

21.2 a game this season · last 3: 8.7, 16.5, 22.1

What the call rests on

  • Geno Smith: Sleeper's projection, last changed Tue, Oct 27, 2:40 PM ET
  • Caleb Williams: Sleeper's projection, last changed Tue, Oct 27, 2:40 PM ET
  • Sleeper's projections read Tue, Oct 27, 2:47 PM ET.
  • Injury statuses: Sleeper's player list, read Tue, Oct 27, 9:01 AM ET (once a day). Game-day inactives, about 90 minutes before kickoff, come after it.

What could change it before kickoff

  • A projection update of 0.9 points or more in the other direction flips the call; Sleeper keeps adjusting its projections until kickoff, and this page reads them again at most an hour after it last did.
  • Geno Smith plays first (Sun 1:00 PM ET); once his game starts most platforms lock him in or out, before Caleb Williams's late news is known.

Open in Who should I start (your league, more players)

This week’s projections are Sleeper’s, scored with PPR settings. The percentage is how often a projected gap like this held up across the 2025 season; checked against 2026 games (not used to fit it), the stated chances so far run a few points high, so read a 60% call as nearer 55%.