Two players, one answer.

Aaron Rodgers vs Justin Herbert

Any league · Rest of season · Redraft PPR, 12 teams

Stats through week 8 of 2026 (in progress)

Aaron Rodgers · Justin Herbert

Rest of season · redraft ppr, 12 teams

Justin Herbert by 6%

Straight up for the rest of the season, getting Justin Herbert: slight edge. Points left count each player's remaining games (byes out).

 Aaron RodgersJustin Herbert
Value · redraft ppr860911
Rank152nd147th
Projected a game15.615.4
Games left1011
Projected points left156170
This season a game16.8 (7 g)11.7 (6 g)
Dropbacks and runs a game39.334.8
Last three games22, 17, 13.111.6, 11.2, 9.8
Value, last 3 weeks-17-378

Get Herbert for Rodgers (calculator)Get Rodgers for Herbert (calculator)Who to start this weekAaron RodgersJustin Herbert

Workload is this season's average. Value moves over three weeks are relative to the rest of the board.