Scouting report · QB · NY Giants
J.J. McCarthy
QB32 in Superflex dynasty leagues, and still climbing the age curve.
#134 overall · age 23 · 2024 round 1, pick 10 · 3rd season
NYGQuarterback · QB32
PPR points a game
Value · Dynasty SF
1,825
▼ 565 · 3 weeks
Rank
#134 · QB32
Overall · position
2026 PPR / game
9.2
QB35 at the position
Age
23
3 seasons in
In a year
+5%
1,911 · about #124 next year
Every format
12-team leagues. Tap a format to see him in it.
Where his value comes from · Dynasty SF
This season 6%Next two seasons 23%Later 71%
His projection (12.1 a game) doesn't clear a replacement-level quarterback yet, so his value is all upside: the chance he becomes more than that, which is real for a 23-year-old this early in his career.
Splits
Regular season · week 7 of 2026 (in progress)
| Season | G | Cmp | Att | Pass yds | Pass TD | Int | Rush yds | Rush TD | PPR / G |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 10 | 140 | 243 | 1,632 | 11 | 12 | 181 | 4 | 13.7 |
| 2026 | 3 | 31 | 49 | 495 | 1 | 1 | 29 | 0 | 9.2 |
2026 week by week · PPR points
What he's worth in a trade
Dynasty SF
Real trades · 33 in the last year
What managers actually gave for J.J. in completed trades in public Sleeper leagues, leagues like Dynasty SF first. No league or manager names. Values have moved since some of these. 4 lopsided at today's values (a dump, or an injury since) are left out.
- Oct 2026 · 14-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy for Jalen Milroe + 2027 2ndCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 2026 · 12-team dynasty SuperflexJameis Winston + Tanner McKee + J.J. McCarthy for Jalen HurtsCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy + 2027 4th for Deebo Samuel Sr.Check it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 2026 · 12-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy for 2028 2ndCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Sep 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy for Aaron Jones Sr.Check it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Aug 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexTank Bigsby + J.J. McCarthy + 2028 1st + 2027 1st for Justin Herbert + 2027 2ndCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
Equal value today · Swindlr's estimate
Not real trades: packages that land within a few percent of J.J.'s value in Dynasty SF now. Open one in the calculator to see who wins it.
In your league
Make the move for J.J..
Values are Swindlr's estimates for 12-team leagues, updated with every week's stats (through week 7 of 2026 (in progress)). "In a year" is the same production a year older, on the age curve the model is tuned with; news, role changes and the next rookie class aren’t in it. Stats: nflverse (CC-BY 4.0).
Stats from nflverse’s box scores through week 7 of 2026 (in progress); teams and injuries from Sleeper, Oct 26. Where the numbers come from.