Scouting report · QB · NY Giants
J.J. McCarthy
QB32 in Superflex TE-premium dynasty leagues, and still climbing the age curve.
#136 overall · age 23 · 2024 round 1, pick 10 · 3rd season
NYGQuarterback · QB32
PPR points a game
Value · SF TE+
1,840
▼ 558 · 3 weeks
Rank
#136 · QB32
Overall · position
2026 PPR / game
9.2
QB35 at the position
Age
23
3 seasons in
In a year
+5%
1,927 · about #125 next year
Every format
12-team leagues. Tap a format to see him in it.
Where his value comes from · SF TE+
This season 6%Next two seasons 23%Later 71%
His projection (12.1 a game) doesn't clear a replacement-level quarterback yet, so his value is all upside: the chance he becomes more than that, which is real for a 23-year-old this early in his career.
Splits
Regular season · week 7 of 2026 (in progress)
| Season | G | Cmp | Att | Pass yds | Pass TD | Int | Rush yds | Rush TD | PPR / G |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 10 | 140 | 243 | 1,632 | 11 | 12 | 181 | 4 | 13.7 |
| 2026 | 3 | 31 | 49 | 495 | 1 | 1 | 29 | 0 | 9.2 |
2026 week by week · PPR points
What he's worth in a trade
SF TE+
Real trades · 33 in the last year
What managers actually gave for J.J. in completed trades in public Sleeper leagues, leagues like SF TE+ first. No league or manager names. Values have moved since some of these. 4 lopsided at today's values (a dump, or an injury since) are left out.
- Oct 2026 · 14-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy for Jalen Milroe + 2027 2ndCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 2026 · 12-team dynasty SuperflexJameis Winston + Tanner McKee + J.J. McCarthy for Jalen HurtsCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy + 2027 4th for Deebo Samuel Sr.Check it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Oct 2026 · 12-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy for 2028 2ndCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Sep 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexJ.J. McCarthy for Aaron Jones Sr.Check it at today's values, in its league's settings
- Aug 2026 · 10-team dynasty SuperflexTank Bigsby + J.J. McCarthy + 2028 1st + 2027 1st for Justin Herbert + 2027 2ndCheck it at today's values, in its league's settings
Equal value today · Swindlr's estimate
Not real trades: packages that land within a few percent of J.J.'s value in SF TE+ now. Open one in the calculator to see who wins it.
In your league
Make the move for J.J..
Values are Swindlr's estimates for 12-team leagues, updated with every week's stats (through week 7 of 2026 (in progress)). "In a year" is the same production a year older, on the age curve the model is tuned with; news, role changes and the next rookie class aren’t in it. Stats: nflverse (CC-BY 4.0).
Stats from nflverse’s box scores through week 7 of 2026 (in progress); teams and injuries from Sleeper, Oct 26. Where the numbers come from.